Marxism More Than Antisemitism Is Responsible for University Riots
For the politically illiterate, the Palestinian cause is an easy sell. Concepts like “genocide,” “occupation,” “ethnic cleansing,” “liberation,” and “free Palestine” have been used to undermine and proselytize students into the political cult that is Marxism. A 3,000-year-old history set against a decades-long ideological campaign would seem overwhelmingly easy enough to paint a clear picture of knowledge. The fact that a Palestinian identity is a synthetic invention and has no basis for legitimate claims goes unnoticed. The radical Left’s dialectical maneuver for political power has exploited Islamism’s October 7 attack on Israel beyond the imagination of many. We are witnessing a low-level, quasi-insurrection at high-profile American university campuses where the existing order is being challenged.
Allan Bloom's classic, The Closing of the American Mind (1987), warned about dangers of curriculum changes, which began in the 1960s and gained a foothold by the 1970s, in the U.S. higher educational system. The Jewish American philosopher argued that this posed a threat to democracy and freedom of thought and expression. The “changes” Bloom noted, all stemmed from intellectual inroads that drew their fire from Marxist Critical Theory. The extension of a series of grievance studies programs with inherent postmodern appendages has succeeded in virtually monopolizing U.S. university courses. There is an ignoramus student body that has been indoctrinated as planned.
It is disappointing and dangerous to see the bulk of the American political class and media commentators dwelling on the symptoms rather than the cause. The recent passage of the “Antisemitism Awareness Act” in the House of Representatives (still pending Senate approval) is an example of this erroneous perception. This “hate speech” legislation is horrific, as far as a free society is concerned. It curtails freedom of expression, is counterproductive to Israeli interests, and excuses the unwillingness of public officials to enforce existing civil rights laws.
The virulent attacks on Jews and the State of Israel in university campuses are clear, as is the unlawful takeover of public spaces and common university premises. However, the opinion that the protests and attacks on Jewry and the Jewish state are primarily grounded in antisemitism is simplistic and flawed. It overlooks an overarching underlying element that is present and substantiates this action. The context of the Palestinian “liberation” cause is at the heart of what drives the young university Jacobins to fanatism.
Herbert Marcuse, Franz Fanon, Edward Said, and Jean Paul Sartre are more responsible for these subversive actions that are being displayed, than hatred of the Torah, the Old Testament (Hebrew Bible), the Talmud, or Zionism. Critical Post-Colonial Theory, a variant of the Frankfurt School’s concocted Critical Theory series of revolutionary calls to war premised on selected oppressor/oppressed dichotomies, underpins these acts. The British and French Mandates lawfully carved out West Asia and the Middle East from the partition of the Ottoman Empire. The State of Israel came to be, as did the modern-day states of Jordan, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Lebanon, Iraq, and Egypt. Palestinian Arabs, it should be noted, were also given territory and the opportunity to form a state, but they rejected the offer. The former Soviet Union and the international communist community capitalized on this and immediately partnered with Arab nationalists linked to the geographical zone of Palestine. Thus began the Marxist wars to “free” Palestine and the invention of the labeled Palestinian identity.
The rogue acts of subversion happening on U.S. campuses are well funded and organized. The money that underwrites many of the groups that are logistically coordinating the vandalism, protests, and public space occupations and destruction is a major donor to far-left groups, causes, and Democratic Party politicians. This includes benefactors of President Joe Biden. Mega tax-exempt structures such as the Tides Foundation, Tides Center, Libra Foundation, Rockefeller Brothers Fund, and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation have, at different intervals, flowed generous amounts of money to the most aggressive ultra-left movements spearheading the pro-Hamas protests.
Groups like the Jewish Voice for Peace, IfNotNow, Palestine Legal, Solidaire Action, Climate Justice Alliance, Black Organizing for Leadership and Dignity, and Immigrant Defense Project are some of the field militias that have spearheaded the despicable acts. All have received funding from one or more of the tax-protected donor conglomerates mentioned previously. Who heads these donor organizations? George Soros, Nicholas and Susan Pritzker (heirs of the Hyatt Hotel empire), Bill and Melinda Gates, and David Rockefeller Jr. It is well to note that Soros and the Pritzker’s are Jewish. This should emphasize the point that antisemitism is not the principle instigating factor.
The common denominator of this multidenominational force seeking to disrupt civility and challenge the American democratic order is Marxism, epistemologically, particularly Critical Theory, and globalist socialism, methodologically. In other words, Marxist doctrines are the most suitable intellectual frameworks, considering their emotional appeal. The practical finale is a Fabian socialist-like centralized globalized order. The State of Israel is, for them, part of Western civilization. Israel and non-Marxist Jews embody, according to this Marxist-Islamic alliance, white supremacist, colonialist, and patriarchal structures of power. The domestic problem of terrorist apologia and activism in American universities and cities is Marxism.
© The CubanAmerican Voice. All rights reserved.
🖋️Author Julio M. Shiling
Julio M. Shiling is a political scientist, writer, columnist, lecturer, media commentator, and director of Patria de Martí and The CubanAmerican Voice. He holds a master’s degree in Political Science from Florida International University (FIU) in Miami, Florida. He is a member of The American Political Science Association and The PEN Club (Cuban Writers in Exile Chapter).
Follow Julio on:
📚Published books 📺In the media 👨🏫 Conferences and Symposiums 🎙️Podcast The Shiling Summary