Pandemic & Biological Warfare

UCLA-Stanford U study: Covid death rates much lower than projected.

Covid death rates much lower than projected

UCLA-Stanford U study: Covid death rates much lower than projected. What’s your risk from coronavirus? Lower than we think, new study suggests. But critics say the study oversimplified answers to one of COVID-19’s most vexing questions

Months into the new coronavirus pandemic, researchers are grappling with an urgent question: How much risk do we have of catching COVID-19 — or dying from it — from our chance encounters?

The debate has flared as authorities find themselves alternately accused of moving too fast or not fast enough in easing restrictions so more business and activity can resume.

Overall, it’s probably less now than many likely believe, given the daily drumbeat of new cases, hospitalizations and deaths, according to new research this month by a pair of medical scientists at Stanford University and UCLA.


“Across the country, current probabilities of infection transmission, hospitalization, and death from COVID19 vary substantially, yet severe outcomes are still rare events,” the study said. “Individuals may be overestimating their risks of hospitalization and death and a moderate number and frequency of community contacts is unlikely to overwhelm hospital capacity in most U.S. settings.”

But like other research challenging assumptions about the disease’s danger, the new findings — yet to be certified through peer review — also raised concerns from other researchers and officials who argue it underplays the virus’s threat.

The risk study by Dr. Rajiv Bhatia, clinical assistant professor of primary care and population health at Stanford, and Dr. Jeffrey Klauser, adjunct professor of epidemiology at UCLA, looked at publicly available case incidence data for the week ending May 30 in the 100 largest U.S. counties as states began to reopen.

“The thing we are looking for is to start a discussion of risk,” Bhatia said. “We’re bombarded with data on death and cases.”

The study found a person in a typical medium to large U.S. county who has a single random contact with another person has, on average, a 1 in 3,836 chance of being infected without social distancing, hand-washing or mask-wearing.


If that sounds like a tolerable risk, consider the odds of being hospitalized. The study found a 50-to-64-year-old person who has a single random contact has, on average, a 1 in 852,000 chance of being hospitalized or a 1 in 19.1 million chance of dying based on rates as of the last week of May.

“We were surprised how low the relative risk was,” Klausner said.

The study assumes the same risk for every individual, even though it is known to be higher in certain regions, occupations and residential settings where there have been repeated outbreaks — meat-packing plants, nursing homes, health care jobs, jails and prisons. The study also did not account for a person’s pre-existing health conditions.

And the report did not attempt to compare the risk levels for infection, hospitalization and death from COVID-19 to other infectious diseases or potential dangers such as automobile accidents, which the authors acknowledged is a more difficult exercise. A 2017 report from the National Safety Council calculated the odds of a person dying in a motor vehicle crash at 1-in-114 and dying from a lightning strike at 1-in-161,856. But that’s over a lifetime, not just a single week.

A. Marm Kilpatrick, an infectious disease researcher at UC Santa Cruz, questioned underlying assumptions in the research after reading the paper and said it is “badly flawed.” He was among scientists who also took issue with a Stanford study in April suggesting the virus is more widespread and less lethal than authorities have assumed.

Santa Clara County Executive Jeff Smith, whose administration led the Bay Area in a regional shelter-in-place order and has taken some criticism for its slow pace of reopening, said after reviewing the study its conclusions are “misleading and not helpful.” He noted that the more than 116,000 U.S. fatalities from COVID-19 are on par with the country’s military losses in World War I, which he called “unacceptable.”

Bhatia doesn’t dispute that cumulative COVID-19 deaths have been significant but said the study was an assessment only of average risks based on current infection reports, which after months of lockdown are lower than they were in March. The estimated risks represent a single point in the epidemic in late May and will increase if the infection rates increase.

Epidemiologists say the nature of the new coronavirus that can spread invisibly through people who don’t feel ill makes it hard for people to assess their own risk. Tulane University epidemiologist Susan E. Hassig said that unlike say, HIV, which is spread through sex or drug needles, it’s often a mystery how a person was infected with the new coronavirus. Was it talking to a friend at the park or lunch with a co-worker?

A man carries weights during a workout at Metroflex Gym Thursday, May 14, 2020, in Oceanside, Calif. The Southern California gym was open Thursday despite its owner’s arrest last weekend for violating orders that prohibit such businesses from operating under orders to stem the spread of the coronavirus. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull) 

And people don’t have a long history with this new coronavirus from which to develop a sense of risk.

“It’s not like the risk of being struck by lightning,” Hassig said. “We tally that over years, sometimes decades. We’ve been doing the coronavirus for four months, so we’re in a really challenging position where it seems like there’s lots of information but it’s not like it’s data that’s usable to estimate risk.”

Bhatia, deputy health officer for San Francisco from 1998 to 2014, and Klausner have asked the California Department of Public Health to make more COVID-19 case report data available so researchers can refine the risks much more closely for settings and occupations, allowing people to better protect themselves.

“This is the best we could do without more data partitioning the risk in different settings,” Bhatia said. “Yes, the risks are probably lower than most people might perceive. But we could, with better data, make this much more precise.”

Did you like it? Share your thoughts!

Share your thoughts on this article!

Source or Author Info
The Mercury News, covering news, sports, business, entertainment and more in Silicon Valley and beyond since 1851

Cultural Marxism

Research finds crt in schools not about racial discrimination

Research Finds CRT in Schools Not About Racial Discrimination

Just the News
Research Finds CRT in Schools Not About Racial Discrimination. Research surprise: Embrace of CRT, 'diversity' agendas in schools not correlated with race. Pilot study of San Diego County school districts finds many dominated by "underrepresented minorities" eschew these controversial concepts. A school district's… Read full article
Where are the Feminists

Where are the Feminists?

Where are the Feminists?. While the Taliban barbarically repress women in Afghanistan, toxic feminists wage a war against American men. Freedom Center Shillman Fellow Bruce Bawer’s excellent Frontpage article "Where Are the Gays?" paints a chilling portrait of the imminent torture, execution and amputations that await… Read full article
space force officer punished after denouncing marxism

Space Force Officer, Punished After Denouncing Marxism

The Space Force officer who was removed from his command post for condemning Marxism and critical race theory is leaving the military. Lt. Col. Matthew Lohmeier told The Epoch Times’ “American Thought Leaders” that his last day in the service will be Sept. 1. “I wrote a letter to then-Acting Secretary of the Air Force… Read full article
utah blm founder us flag a hate symbol

Utah BLM Founder: US Flag a Hate Symbol

Utah BLM Founder: US Flag a "Hate" Symbol. In a Facebook post made on Independence Day, Utah’s Black Lives Matter (BLM) Chapter wrote that the American flag is “a symbol of hatred” and those flying are “racist.” “When we Black Americans see this flag, we know the person flying it is not safe to be around,” the post… Read full article

Socialist War in US

Popular in Pandemia

Your Government is Lying to You Covid19

Former Pfizer VP: Your Gov't is Lying to You

Former Pfizer VP: Your government is lying to you in a way that could lead to your death. Dr. Michael Yeadon, Pfizer's former Vice President and Chief Scientist for Allergy & Respiratory who spent 32 years in the industry leading new medicines research and…
Coronaphobia is more dangerous than virus

Coronaphobia is more dangerous than virus

Coronaphobia is more dangerous than virus. We Need a Principled Anti-Lockdown Movement Shell-shocked is a good way to describe the mood in the U.S. for a good part of the Spring of 2020. Most of us never thought it could happen here. I certainly did not, even…
More than 300K veterans died as result of Obama Biden negligence

More than 300K veterans died as result of Obama/Biden negligence

More than 300K veterans died as result of Obama/Biden negligence. This Obama-Biden Administration Failure Killed More Americans Than COVID-19. Everyone on the left is trying to blame Donald Trump for COVID-19 and the deaths caused by it. Gov. Andrew Cuomo is…
Report challenges Fauci's lockdown theories

Report challenges Fauci's lockdown theories

Report challenges Fauci's lockdown theories. Fact-Checking Fauci, the primary architect of the Trump administration’s COVID response, painted a bleak picture about the EEUU's ability to contain the pandemic. In recent congressional testimony Dr. Anthony…
16K doctors scientists oppose 2nd covid lockdown

16K doctors/scientists oppose 2nd covid lockdown

16K doctors/scientists oppose 2nd covid lockdown. They believe lockdown measures are not only completely unnecessary, but also have a devastating impact on physical and mental health as well as society. The Facts: More than 16000 scientists and doctors, as…
Left lies about coronavirus Nancy Pelos Chuck Schume

The left lies about coronavirus

The left lies about coronavirus. BEWARE: Democrats Are Pushing These Four COVID-19 Lies. Beware of three widely circulating COVID-19-related lies and the partisan motives behind them. These lies are dangerous to your children and how you cope with this virus.…
Joe Biden Restart Funding to Shady Wuhan Lab

Did Joe Biden Restart Funding to Shady Wuhan Lab?

Did Joe Biden Restart Funding to Shady Wuhan Lab?. President Biden has committed to providing the WHO with $200 million in US taxpayer dollars. Twitter is abuzz with rage this afternoon(February18) at reports that President Joe Biden has restarted funding to…
Death Certificates May be Edited Covid19

Death Certificates May be Edited for Covid

++ Death Certificates May be Edited for Covid. Funeral aid program allows death certificates to be altered for those who 'may have' died of COVID. Relatives of individuals who died in the "early days" of the coronavirus pandemic will be able to seek amended…
Trump Blames FDA Deep State for Coronavirus Vaccine Delay

Trump Blames FDA 'Deep State' for Coronavirus Vaccine Delay

President Donald Trump on Saturday accused the “deep state” in the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) of delaying a vaccine for the coronavirus. “The deep state, or whoever, over at the FDA is making it very difficult for drug companies to get people in…
Recover Better Together: Taiwan can help

Recover Better Together: Taiwan can help

Recover Better Together: Taiwan can help. With fewer than 500 confirmed cases and 7 deaths, Taiwan has defied predictions and successfully contained COVID-19. Said Jaushieh Joseph Wu Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of China (Taiwan). The UN must…
Lockdowns The Rx is worse than the ailment

Lockdowns: The Rx is worse than the ailment

Lockdowns: The Rx is worse than the ailment. The Covid-19 Catastrophe. The lockdowns didn’t just cost millions of people’s livelihoods, they also cost people’s lives. It has been five months since the American people were told they would be under house arrest…
baby vaccine

The price of one-sided Rx

The price of one-sided Rx. Which Diseases Are on the Rise As We Fight COVID-19? The battle against COVID-19 has been a grand and tragic balancing act. The battle against COVID-19 has been a grand and tragic balancing act. Reopening countries prematurely, the…
YouTube censors Ron Paul for questioning Fauci

YouTube censors Ron Paul for questioning Fauci

YouTube censors Ron Paul for questioning Fauci. YouTube has censored a video from former congressman Ron Paul, known for his trailblazing presidential campaigns against the Republican establishment in 2008 and 2012. Paul, who is a medical doctor, was censored…
Doubts and concerns about chinese vaccines

Doubts and concerns about chinese vaccines

Doubts and concerns about Chinese vaccines. Chinese health authorities have approved three coronavirus vaccines (developed by Chinese state-owned enterprises, Sinopharm, Sinovac and CanSino Biologics) despite not having published the results of Phase 3, a…
Chinese virologist covid virus man Made in China

Chinese virologist: "covid virus man-Made in China"

Chinese virologist: "covid virus man-Made in China". Chinese virologist who fled to the US after claiming Beijing covered up Covid-19 vows to publish evidence PROVING the virus is manmade - and claims even non-scientists will be able to verify the data.…

Subscribe to The CubanAmerican Voice

Discover the news hidden and manipulated by the media!

Follow Us:

Go To Top